A WeWork Future: Perpetual Hybrid Work
I published my very first post on Interconnected in late February 2020. Back then, the coronavirus in China was in full swing, but the rest of the world has yet to grasp the gravity of this pandemic.
In that post, I talked about a future where remote work and remote consumption will become mainstream due to COVID-19. It was not an uncommon sentiment, especially if you work in tech. It was also a future that was mostly touted with a utopian sheen. Now that this future has largely become reality, it’s time to address some of the darker, more challenging elements of distributed remote work and the next phase of this evolution, which I call “perpetual hybrid work”.
Two years into this pandemic-turned-endemic, addressing these challenges is particularly timely given that multiple tech CEO’s have shared hiring data that validates the increasingly dispersed nature of technology and knowledge workers. This “perpetual hybrid work” future also bodes well for one specific company that has been the laughing stock of tech: WeWork.
Global Tech Talent Dispersion
For anyone who works in tech, especially if you are in charge of recruiting, hiring, and managing people, you have probably intuitively felt the physical dispersion of coworkers in the last two years. Last week, several CEOs voluntarily shared some numbers on Twitter that support this intuition. Here is the comparison of the percentages of hiring done outside the San Francisco/Silicon Valley, pre-pandemic versus the present day, among three top-tier tech companies:
Stripe:
- Q1 2019 (pre-pandemic): 39%
- Q4 2021 (most recent quarter): 74%
Coinbase:
- Q1 2019: 30%
- Q4 2021: 89%
Cloudflare:
- Q1 2019: 48%
- Today: 78%
Now, remote work and global hiring is not necessarily new in tech, especially if you work in pure software. Notable companies like Automattic and GitLab have been remote-first from day one. What is noteworthy with Stripe, Coinbase, and Cloudflare validating the same trend is that all three companies have committed serious commercial real estate investment to the SF/Bay Area. (I have been to all three companies’ offices pre-pandemic; they are nice!) So this transition is more painful and costly to them, which underscores just how real this trend of global tech talent dispersion really is.
San Francisco and Silicon Valley are no longer the default physical center of gravity. But what replaces them is not no physical center of gravity whatsoever, but many smaller physical centers of gravity to alleviate the struggles of distributed remote work.
Remote Work Struggles
I have been working in a distributed remote work setting since 2017, so I’ll share some of the challenges and difficulties that are unique to this way of working.
These are not hypothetical struggles you read about in an MBA case study or HR handbook. These are struggles I have personally seen, felt, and experienced as an operator over the last five years, categorized from the eyes of three common personas:
If you are an employee who is early in your career, you struggle with:
- Receiving quality mentorship and career guidance
- Building a support network with other similar employees
- Managing and balancing workload independently
- Building a professional identity
If you are an employee who has a young family, you struggle with:
- Balancing work and family responsibilities (especially if your school or childcare option is unreliable)
- Concentrating without distractions at home
- Feeling secure that having your child/children appear unexpectedly in your video calls don’t negatively impact your career advancement
If you are a manager, you struggle with:
- Understanding each team member’s goals, aspirations, struggles, and incentives
- Running productive meetings, planning sessions, and brainstorming exercises
- Establishing cross-functional collaborative relationships with other managers
- Balancing meetings across many time zones, oftentimes across many countries
The manager struggles I laid out are especially pronounced if you manage team members with whom you don’t have a previous working relationship with (very likely, given the high level of current turnover and competition over talent in the tech industry).
This list of struggles is by no means exhaustive. Many of them existed pre-pandemic and pre-remote work. Many of them have been exacerbated during the pandemic when distributed remote work became the norm, but new norms have yet to be formed to address these worsening struggles.
Regular (but not daily) in-person work cannot solve all these problems but can alleviate many of them, especially ones that have to do with relationship building, creative collaboration, and knowing your colleagues on a deeper level. They require intuiting people’s emotions via their body language, facial expression, and other observations that are almost impossible to gather over hours of Zoom calls. They are, however, essential to tech and frankly all knowledge work industries.
Knowledge workers are done with 100% remote work from home. People need offices, just not all the time. That’s what “perpetual hybrid work” means.
But with the single corporate headquarters structure becoming obsolete, as Stripe, Coinbase, and Cloudflare’s hiring practice suggests, where can these smaller, dispersed physical centers of gravity pop up?
WeWork.
A WeWork Future
WeWork is still the most recognizable commercial real estate brand in the world and in a largely positive way. Despite its massive and well-documented first attempted IPO failure, most entrepreneurs and operators don’t really care. They just need easily accessible and well-designed office spaces – cheaply and flexibly. Even well before the pandemic, when I had conversations with entrepreneurs who were looking to expand to new markets overseas or set up their first work location somewhere, the solution was not “find an office”, it was “get a WeWork”. When I visited Mexico last February to explore the local tech ecosystem, the WeWork building in Mexico City where Didi’s local office is located was humming with activities.
Although WeWork is definitively not a tech company (it now calls itself “the leading flexible space provider”), it is the most tech-friendly, tech-enabled commercial real estate company.
One case in point is Coinbase, one of our “perpetual hybrid work” protagonists, is a large WeWork customer. Catering to Coinbase and the fast-growing crypto space, WeWork announced in April 2021 that it’ll accept many forms of cryptocurrencies as payment. While there are other smaller, local co-working spaces that also accept crypto, like Primalbase (the Netherlands), Hub Hoi An (Vietnam), Krakow (Poland), WeWork is the only one with a real global footprint that accepts crypto to my knowledge. With offices in literally every city that has a modicum of tech, you can basically visualize where all the smaller centers of gravity are by looking at WeWork’s clusters of office distribution:
Accepting crypto is a shrewd move given that $33 billion of VC money has been poured into the crypto industry in 2021 alone. All of these well-funded crypto startups recruit, hire, and work in a distributed remote work way. All of them will need to get more than a few WeWork’s to build their company. The same goes for most software companies, especially ones that have no large office lease commitments.
Well-designed physical spaces where people can meet, work, collaborate, and create in-person still matter. Whether you call it offices, co-working spaces, hangouts, or whatever is cool and appealing, people still need to see people beyond their screens.
WeWork went public via a SPAC merger last October at a modest valuation of roughly $9 billion. This successful public listing received much less fanfare than its first failed public listing, but the “perpetual hybrid work” macro environment could not have been more favorable for WeWork.
WeWork projects that it will become profitable sometime within 2022. Now, I don’t know enough about the commercial real estate business to say whether this projection is yet another “old WeWork's Adam Neumann puffery” or a different “new WeWork pragmatism” led by Masa Son's lieutenants, Marcelo Claure and Sandeep Mathrani. But if WeWork does not become profitable, it will not be because of a lack of opportunity or tailwind.
“Perpetual hybrid work” is still in its early days, and globally-available flexible office space is the key to making it all work. It’s a tailwind that will be blowing for a long, long time.
WeWork的未来:“永久的混合式办公”
早在2020年2月,我在《互联》上发表了第一篇文章。那时,中国的疫情非常严重,但世界其他地方还没有意识到整个疫情的严重性。
在那篇文章中,我谈到了由于疫情,远程办公和远程消费将成为未来的主流形式。这个观点并不算很独特,尤其是如果你在科技行业办公。当时,这一观点也大多被吹捧为具有乌托邦色彩的未来。现在,这个未来在很大程度上已经成为现实,是时候分析讨论分布式远程办公形式的一些更黑暗、更具挑战性的现象了。大趋势演变的下一阶段,即是我称之为的 "永久混合式办公"。
全世界已经度过了长达两年的疫情,现在来面对这些挑战特别及时。多个科技公司的CEO已经分享了各自的招聘数据,验证了科技和知识办公力日益分散的大趋势。这种 "永久混合式办公"的未来也预示着一家一直被当作科技界笑柄的公司的崛起:WeWork。
全球科技人才的分散
任何在科技领域办公的人,特别如果你负责招聘、雇人和管理的话,可能已经直观地感受到过去两年里同事们的逐渐分散。上周,几位CEO自愿在Twitter上分享了一组验证这种直觉的招聘数据。以下是三家一线科技公司在疫情前后,在旧金山/硅谷以外地区招聘比例的比较:
Stripe:
- 2019年第一季度(疫情前):39%。
- 2021年第四季度(最近一个季度):74%。
Coinbase:
- Q1 2019: 30%
- Q4 2021: 89%
Cloudflare:
- Q1 2019: 48%
- Today: 78%
远程办公和全球范围招聘在科技界内并不是什么新鲜事,尤其是纯软件行业。像Automattic和GitLab这样的知名公司从一开始就以远程办公为先。但值得注意的是,Stripe、Coinbase和Cloudflare验证的趋势的背景是,这三家公司都在旧金山/湾区花了重金投入地产和建造办公室(我曾在疫情前亲自去过这三家公司在湾区的总部,都建的很棒!)。因此,这种转型对它们来说更加痛苦,成本更高,也更强调了这股全球科技人才分散的趋势是多么真实。
旧金山和硅谷不再是科技公司的默认重心,但取代它的不是没有任何重心,而是许多较小的重心,以减轻分布式远程办公的多种困难。
远程办公的困难
自2017年以来,我一直在分布式远程办公环境下工作,所以想分享这种办公方式所特有的一些挑战和困难。
这些困难不是在什么MBA案例里或HR手册中的假设困难,而是我过去五年在运营公司过程中亲自看到的、感受到的、体验到的挣扎,从三个常见的办公职位的角度分类总结:
如果你是个较年轻、处于职业生涯早期的员工,会在以下方面遇到困难:
- 获得高质量的导师指导和职业指导
- 与其他情况类似的年轻员工建立关系和社交基础
- 独立的管理和平衡工作量
- 打造一个职业身份(professional identity)
如果你是个有小家庭的员工,会在以下方面遇到困难:
- 平衡工作和家庭责任(尤其是当学校或托儿所不可靠的情况下)
- 在家办公时很难专心,经常被家事打断
- 确保当孩子意外出现在视频会议背景中时,不会对职业发展产生负面影响
如果你是个经理,会在以下方面遇到困难:
- 了解团队的每个成员的个人目标、意愿、挣扎和激励方式
- 组织成效高的会议、工作计划和头脑风暴活动
- 与其他经理建立跨职能的合作关系
- 平衡不同时区的会议,通常是跨国会议
如果你管理的团队成员与你以前没有过工作历史(鉴于目前科技行业的高流动率和人才竞争,这是很有可能的),那么我列出的经理人的各种困难就更加明显。
以上列出的困难绝不是详尽的。许多困难在疫情和远程办公流行之前就存在,但当分布式远程办公成为常态时,其中的困难被加剧了。可是“新常态”还没有形成,还没能帮助解决这些不断恶化的挑战。
定期(但不是每天)面对面的办公并不能完全解决这些问题,但可以缓解许多问题,特别是那些与建立人际关系、创造性合作和更深层次地了解同事有关的障碍。需要通过摸索人的肢体语言、面部表情和其他当面观察抓捕每个人的情绪,这些都是几个小时的视频会议完全无法做到的。然而,无论是科技行业还是所有知识性行业,这又是必不可少的。
各大知识性行业的员工们已经受不了100%的在家远程办公形式了。大家需要办公室,只是不是每天需要,这就是 "永久混合式办公"的意义。
那随着公司总部式结构逐渐过时,正如Stripe、Coinbase和Cloudflare的招聘经验所证明的那样,那些较小的、分散的办公重心能在哪里出现呢?
WeWork.
WeWork的未来
WeWork仍然是世界上最知名的商业地产品牌,而且品牌印象总体还是很正面的。尽管它在首次尝试上市时遭遇了巨大的、有据可查的失败,但大多数创业者和运营者并不在乎。他们只需要一个便宜、灵活、容易获取和设计良好的办公空间。甚至在疫情之前,当我与许多创业者交流时,他们在希望向海外新市场扩张或在某城市设立第一个办公地点时,通常的结论不是 "找个办公室",而是 "找个WeWork"。我去年2月访问墨西哥,去探索当地的科技生态,就看到墨西哥城的WeWork大楼,也是滴滴当地的办公总部,热闹非凡。
尽管WeWork绝对不是一家科技公司(它现在称自己为 "领先的灵活空间供应商"),但它是对科技界最友好的、技术成分最多的商业房地产公司。
一个例子就是Coinbase,我们的 "永久混合式办公" 的主角之一,也是WeWork的大客户。为了迎合Coinbase和快速增长的加密货币行业,WeWork在2021年4月宣布,将接受多种形式的加密货币作为支付手段。虽然有其他较小的,更当地的共享办公空间也接受加密货币,如Primalbase(荷兰)、Hub Hoi An(越南)、Krakow(波兰),但是据我所知,WeWork是唯一一个真正具有全球规模的接受加密货币的共享办公空间供应商。WeWork基本在每个有一点科技生态的城市都有办公室,看WeWork的全球办公点密集程度,就基本上可以看到所有的“混合式办公”的小重心所在处了。
鉴于仅在2021年就有330亿美元的风投资金涌入加密货币行业,接受加密货币是一个精明之举。所有这些资金充足的加密货币初创公司都在疯狂地招聘雇人,并都以分布式远程办公的方式工作。它们都需要好几个WeWork来把公司搭建起来,大多数软件公司也是如此,尤其是那些没有太多办公室租赁承诺和投资的公司。
精心设计的办公空间,能让大家面对面地办公、协作和创造,这一体验仍然很重要。无论你把它称为是办公室、共享办公空间、聚会场所,还是其他时髦、吸引人的说法,人仍需要在屏幕以外看到其他人。
去年10月,WeWork通过SPAC合并方式上市,估值不高,为大约90亿美元。这次成功的上市比其第一次失败的上市受到的关注要少得多,但 "永久混合式办公" 这个宏观大环境对WeWork来说再有利不过了。
WeWork预计将在2022年内达到盈利。我对商业地产业务了解不多,也不敢说这一预测是又一次 "老WeWork的Adam Neumann吹嘘",还是一家不同的、由孙正义的大将Marcelo Claure和Sandeep Mathrani领导的"新WeWork的务实"。 但是,如果WeWork不能实现盈利,原因绝对不会是缺乏机遇或顺风。
"永久的混合式办公" 仍处于早期阶段,而有全球规模的灵活办公空间服务则是推动它的关键。这是一股将会吹很长、很长一段时间的风。
如果您喜欢所读的内容,请用email订阅加入“互联”。要想读以前的文章,请查阅《互联档案》。每周一篇新文章送达您的邮箱。请在Twitter、LinkedIn、Clubhouse(@kevinsxu)上给个follow,和我交流互动!